Cathedral Thinking

Nathan Willis wrote an article highlighting some recent problems on open source projects and referenced the idea of Cathedral Thinking.

But that absence of an open invitation to contribute is topped by direct rejection. In August, an excited would-be participant learned about the project and wrote to the gimp-developer mailing list volunteering to help. GIMP UI Redesign team leader Peter Sikking replied, saying, “I am afraid that I do not have positions open at the moment.”

Elsewhere in that same message, and in other posts to gimp-developer, Sikking’s comments back up the notion that he regards the GIMP UI redesign as his team’s project and his team’s alone, and that that team has no room for anyone else.

Clearly the team members are qualified, but refusing to entertain even the possibility that there are other individuals with worthwhile contributions flies in the face of free software and open source ideals. It is Cathedral thinking, not Bazaar.

When open source projects close the process, something’s wrong (linux.com)

Welcome to CathedralThinking.com.  The initial goal of this website will be to help people understand the idea of Cathedral thinking and what it means in terms of ideas ranging from the environment to the open source movement.  Over time this site will hopefully be a go-to place for people wishing to understand the concept of Cathedral Thinking and find the resources that help define it.